Hell’s Kitchen: Is Reality Television Ethical?
We all have a guilty pleasure. For some it may be gossip magazines, for others it may be
sweets. For myself, it’s trashy reality shows. There is something about viewing the drama while
staying a good distance away from it that scratches a borderline toxic itch. One of these shows I
have watched nearly every season of is Hell’s Kitchen, hosted by Gordon Ramsay. Debuting in
2005, the show begins with twelve contestants competing to be the next head chef of Ramsay’s
brand new restaurant. The group is split into two teams, men versus women. They endure many
different challenges during the day, like blind palate taste testing or cooking a dish with an
unusual list of ingredients. In the evening, the two teams cook and serve the Hell’s Kitchen
restaurant. The dining room is split in half, one side blue and the other red, the two kitchens
serve the different sides of the room respectively. Whichever team serves every table on their
side first wins that evening and is safe from elimination.
There are many ways this reality show becomes dysfunctional pretty quickly, one of them
being that every night in each episode, the losing team has to discuss with one another their
faults and who they thought was the downfall of the team. This escalates the situation and turns
everyone against each other. The losing team of the night then has to put two people up for
elimination with proceeding explanations. Gordon Ramsay has to decide who he is going to send
home, and the episode concludes with many catty remarks in the talking heads, and a final
remark of why Ramsay is very disappointed in the contestant sent home. A similar situation
occurred in the earlier seasons of the show where Ramsay would be absolutely brutal towards the
contestants during every challenge, every service, every episode. He would call the team
members hurtful names, question their qualifications as chefs, and scream at them at his fullest
volume. Instances like these made the audience question the moral integrity of the show and
whether or not people should even be allowed to subject themselves to this kind of behavior.
In 2013, a new show debuted, Master Chef Junior. It is a spin off of the cooking
competition Master Chef, but with children as the contestants. Who else would be one of the
three hosts besides our temperamental friend, Gordon Ramsay. This show is what seems to have
flipped a switch within Ramsay. The young contestants of the show taught him to control his
tongue as well as his temper, oftentimes commenting on how mean he is on the shows they have
seen him in, making him realize his reputation for the next generation was not an admirable one.
During this time back in Hell’s Kitchen, you can see Ramsay beginning to soften towards others
and control his emotions easier. Little by little, he made the show feel less tense as time went on.
Reality television can oftentimes suck us into a world that is distasteful, damaging, and
ruthless. It always makes you sympathetic for the participants of the show, even if they did sign
up for it. Though the ethical standpoint for many reality shows may be erratic, Hell’s Kitchen has
turned its program around with one perspective shift from Ramsay learning his influence on the
world through a child's eyes. Gordon Ramsay has pivoted the general morale of the kitchen
space to be a supportive one, rather than a damaging one, while still pushing the contestants for
greatness, all because of those young chefs.
Hell’s Kitchen did begin as any one of those competitive reality cooking shows you’d see
playing in waiting rooms or restaurants, questioning how it even aired on television. Now it has
transformed into a series with a compassionate and grounded host to guide chefs through their
next journey, and set them up for success through an entertaining and inspiring program. For my
fellow trashy reality show fans, do not despair. Even though Ramsay has grown to be more well
rounded and calm, he can still heat it up in the kitchen when there is an “idiot sandwich” on the
line. It is still Hell’s Kitchen after all.




Comments